What is a PawPaw? A PawPaw looks like a green potato, but tastes like banana and mango custard (with a hint of vanilla and citrus). The flavors of Blood Orange and Basil complement the PawPaw’s tropical flavors, and when combined with our Scrumpy, the result is a smooth and easy hard cider.Why Patriotic? PawPaws are the largest fruit native to America, but most people in the U.S. have never heard of them. Founding Fathers Washington and Jefferson were historical lovers of the PawPaw, as were Lewis and Clark. The PawPaw is a true American! 16 oz Can Price Each.